Dismiss

askville homepage
Hightest Level: 2
Asked by OlneyFalcon 22 months ago ( Send a Compliment)

Details:

Assume the stranger is easier to get to, what is your decision now?

Prefer to hear from serious dog lovers...


0
Forward to Friends Forward to friends
Discuss this question (25 comments) why can't I answer? add to Digg Digg it! add to Facebook Add to Facebook Report abuse

av-answers (5)
(25)
 
show all details - hide all details

"I feel terrible saying this but it would have to be my dog...... in most cases"

Hightest Level: 5 by Doglover928 on Jan 12 2008 (22 months ago)
Best Answer Winner! Best Answer
Official Rating
Four and a half stars

I know...a dog is not a person technically, but emotionally it is to me.  There is no way I could let one of my dogs go.

 

However, there could be circumstances that may change the scenario. Suppose the person was a child and the dog was my eldest dog, Mandy, who is 10.  Although she most likely has several years left, she has had a good long life, and in that case I would save the child for sure.  It would be really hard, but I could not let a child drown for anything.  In the case of my Sierra, who is my soul-mate and my sweet baby girl, although she is almost 8, I would have to let her go also, it there was a child involved.  But this scenario makes me flounder. She means more to me than any dog that I have ever owned, and I cannot bear to think of letting her drown. This question is really turning out to be a disturbing one.  It makes me question my humanity. The thought of making a decision like this tears me apart inside. Could I really let a person go to save my dog? I think I could under the following circumstances.

 

I do think my answer is yes, depending on the age of the human. I would say anyone in their 20’s or less I would save.  I could not let them lose their chance of having children and grandchildren.  Why, they wouldn’t even get to experience having a dog :-)

 

While I would like to say that I would save any human before my dogs, I know if the time came I could not lose my dog. Yes, I do consider them very close to human and a lot easier to live with than people.  I know most people do not agree with that philosophy, but the depth of love for a dog can go deeper and deeper depending on the person.  

 

I am trying to be as honest as I can in this hypothetical (thank God) situation.  I hope no one will think less of me.  Maybe if this dreadful situation actually took place, my response would be different, but this is how I would imagine myself reacting. 

 

 

I hope my Mandy girl will always know how to swim.  The other two dogs are a lost cause :-)

 

 

 

 

Sources: My wavering conscience

Doglover928's Recommendations
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $17.95
Used from: $9.36
Average Customer Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (based on 8 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $14.99
Used from: $3.14
Average Customer Rating: 5.0 out of 5 (based on 1 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $15.95
Used from: $9.19
Average Customer Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (based on 21 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $12.95
Used from: $3.33
Like this Answer? Thumb Up (1)

"The stranger...."

Hightest Level: 3 by marissa on Jan 12 2008 (22 months ago)
Official Rating
Four stars

I adore my pets and I love animals in general.  I have worked with animal rescue organizations for years and done much to try and improve the lives of animals, whether dog, cat or any other creature.  Because I am so passionate about the animals, that has lead some people to wonder if I care more about animals than people.  I know that many others like me have faced the same type of misunderstanding.  We have been asked questions like this one or ones like, "If a house was burning would you try to save the animals inside or the people inside first?"  I have to tell you, in all my years, I have never met anyone who said that they would save the animal over the person (however, maybe someone here would choose the animal over the person, but I doubt it, I'm interested in seeing the other answers).  I care greatly about animals, but I also care greatly about people and I would certainly save a stranger over my dog.

 

Now, let me elaborate beyond the basic idea of saving a person over an animal, other reasons I would save the person over my dog are as follows.  I believe that my dog would pass over to a better place, yes, I believe that animals have spirits and that they pass on to heaven, so although I would miss my fury friend terribly, I would be sad for myself, but not for her.  Plus, in my opinion, my dog would want me to save the stranger.  All the dogs (and cats) that I have known sense when a human is in distress (emotional and/or physical) and want to try and help that person if they can.  Even if it is just laying a comforting head on your lap when you are sad.

Like this Answer? Thumb Up (0)

"The stranger, even though it would be VERY difficult"

Hightest Level: 6 by Goldie. on Jan 12 2008 (22 months ago)
Official Rating
Four stars
I would have to put a human life, any human life, ahead of my dog's life. And if you knew how much I love my dog, you'd know that's saying a lot. My little Pom goes everywhere with me. She is my "soul mate" (shhh, don't tell hubby!). She has a Myspace page, and I post for her there (her itty paws just can't work the keyboard). I tell her all my secrets. I taught her how to swim (unusual for a pom) but she's not a strong swimmer, so this could conceivably happen some day, and it would be the darkest day of my life. I'm fairly sure that when she is gone, I will mourn her like no other.  That dog has been through a LOT with me. From the day I brought her home and she road around the house in my pocket, up to now - 6 years later, there isn't anything that I haven't been willing to do for her. But cost another human his life for her sake? I could never do that.

Now, let's say that you took your question one step further, and said that the person who is drowning is a murderer. Then I'd start to reconsider my earlier statement of "any human life." That would be a very tough call for me, and honestly? Not sure what I'd do.
Like this Answer? Thumb Up (0)

"I have two dogs that I love dearly but I would save the human being first."

Hightest Level: 5 by Christian on Jan 12 2008 (22 months ago)
Official Rating
Four stars
Human life is sacred, even if the man or women were an enemy of mine I would save the human before a dog.  Yet, I would try to save the dogs too.  Both my dogs, though they don't like water much, are great swimmers, so I would be surprised if they drowned anyway, they would find a way out.
Like this Answer? Thumb Up (0)

"I love my dog very much."

Hightest Level: 5 by txteacher on Jan 12 2008 (22 months ago)
Official Rating
Four stars
But...his life is not more precious than that of a human being.  The person I saved could be someone's father, son, or brother.  I love animals and especially dogs, but I don't confuse them with humans.
Like this Answer? Thumb Up (0)




Or ask a question of your own:


 

Latest post on this question's discussion board:

Doglover, wtg getting Best Answer. I gave you 5 stars, as I said, which took you a long way toward that rating, while at the same time I kept thinking this is a sad commentary on society today. What's worse is that you are probably right to feel the way you do...damndest thing...
Read more & discuss (25 comments)