Asked by randall3000 38 months ago

Details:

Or is it just against the terms of service of Visa, etc? Or both?


0
 Forward to friends
 Discuss this question (0 comments) why can't I answer? Report abuse

av-answers (5)
 
Show all details, Hide all details

"Yes and No."

 by BetterKnown on Dec 04 2006 (38 months ago)
 Best Answer
Official Rating

In public law, i.e. under federal and, as far as I know, state law, there is no affirmative duty to accept credit card payments.  Thus it would follow that merchants are free to not accept credit cards for small transactions.  The reason many merchants do not accept credit cards for small dollar amount transactions is because the credit card company charges (1-3%) significantly eat into their profits on these transactions where the margins are much lower than on big-ticket items.

In private law, i.e. contracts, it can be "illegal" for merchants to refuse credit card payments for small transactions.  Often credit card companies will stipulate that merchants must accept credit cards for all transactions.  Thus if a merchant does not accept credit card transactions for small transactions, he could be violating his private law (contractual) obligation to the credit card company.  Customers, however, have little legal recourse here, as the issue is between the merchant and the credit card company, not the merchant and the consumer.  Your only recourse would be to contact your credit card company and ask that they use their clout to pressure a retailer into accepting credit cards for all transactions.  Beware, though, as merchants usually just pass the cost of credit card transactions on to consumers - thus you could see a slight bump in the price of small items.

One option for merchants is to do what Apple does with their online iTunes store (99 cents per song) and aggregate all transactions over a given period (hour, day, week, etc) and treat it as one large transaction.  This has an advantage because credit card companies charge a lower percentage of the total transaction for higher dollar transactions.  This sort of aggregation agreement may, however, be hard for a small merchant to get because he doesn’t have the leverage that Apple has.
Sources: http://www.businessknowhow.com/money/tips5.htm
Like this Answer?  (1)

"It's not "illegal", but technically it IS against their merchants agreement"

 by catnapped on Dec 04 2006 (38 months ago)
Official Rating

All credit cards have a set of rules (called "merchant agreements") which retailers and any other entity which accept their card are expected to abide by. Both Mastercard and Visa state in their merchant agreements that a retailer may not impose a minimum charge, may not impose a surcharge (thought the merchant is allowed to offer a cash discount), may NOT require a second form of ID (driver's license) UNLESS the card is not signed or unless fraud is suspected. Both Discover and AmEX allow merchants to impose a surcharge, but only if they impose a surcharge on ALL payment cards which are accepted at the establishment.

Unfortunately, you will find many merchants which break one or more clauses of their merchant agreement with their provider--either unknowingly, or in some cases, willingly (since they figure no one will call and complain).
Sources: my knowledge
Like this Answer?  (1)

"yep totally legal."

 by newbie181064 on Dec 04 2006 (38 months ago)
Official Rating

it's absolutely legal.  Stores do it because everytime you use a credit card, Visa/MC etc. takes a cut of the sales as their commission so stores have a floor amount that you have to exceed in order to use your card.  They don't want to give away any money on an already small purchase.  Plus there's the extra benefit that that policy encourages you to buy more so that you can charge the purchase.
Like this Answer?

"Yes!"

 by buddhame on Dec 04 2006 (38 months ago)
Official Rating

Visa etc. charges a fee for each transaction. Some merchants cannot afford these fees if small transactions are made. And yes, of course its legal.
Like this Answer?

"absolutely"

 by UAttah on Dec 04 2006 (38 months ago)
Official Rating

It most definitely is. I live in Dallas where there is this huge wholesae district. In most of the stores there, if you transaction is less than $25-- they do cash only. Reason being...whoever they are going through for their merchant services...it's not worth it to have someone charge so little. All profits would essentially be eaten up by Visa/Mastercard or AMex/Discover.  It's rather annoying but completely legal. Hope that helps!
Like this Answer?




Ask a question of your own: