Asked by neetofamily 26 months ago

Details:

My Husbands Daughte ( My Step Daughter ) Is NOT Potty Trained. She is 5 Years Old and No She Does Not Live With Us Full Time.
What Should I Do??? She Thinks It Is Ok No Matter What Her Dad And I Say


0
 Forward to friends
 Discuss this question (4 comments) why can't I answer? Report abuse

av-answers (5)
(4)
 
Show all details, Hide all details

"patience and training with positive reinforcement."

 by Schelli on Dec 10 2007 (26 months ago)
 Best Answer
Official Rating

The first thing I’d do is understand that the first letter of every word in a sentence is not capitalized in normal speech.

 

After that, you need to realize that since she only visits you occassionally, there is not much you can do - even if you can get her potty trained at your place, she has 5 days to lose that training elsewhere.  Ultimately, it’s going to require a great deal of patience on your part, as well as some redirection and coaxing to get her potty trained.  Lead by example - take her to the toilet with you and show her what to do - get one of those kid toilets and put it in the bathroom.  Don’t get angry when she messes up (no pun intended).  Don’t shame her.

 

I would think that a lack of potty training at that age would be the sign of emotional issues, or some emotional/mental retardation occurring.  It’s also possible that there is some abuse going on - this is one of the symptoms, as it’s the only thing the child has control over..  Maybe she’s acting out because she doesn’t like you being with her Daddy and wants Mommy to be there.  Perhaps having her seen by a child psychologist would be a great idea.  Heck, she may have a physical problem - has she been taken to a physician and the doctor told about your concerns?

 

Most school systems require children to be house-broken before they will allow them to come to school, so this is a subject that needs to be addressed for the child’s sake - kids are going to be cruel to her.  I would probably get your husband to start addressing it through the proper channels - the court that granted the divorce.


Schelli's Recommendations
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $12.95
Used from: $6.80
Average Customer Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (based on 171 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $7.99
Used from: $4.42
Average Customer Rating: 4.0 out of 5 (based on 47 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $4.99
Used from: $0.73
Average Customer Rating: 4.0 out of 5 (based on 118 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $5.95
Used from: $0.01
Average Customer Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (based on 68 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $6.99
Used from: $0.79
Average Customer Rating: 3.5 out of 5 (based on 339 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $12.95
Used from: $4.45
Average Customer Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (based on 14 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $6.95
Used from: $3.92
Average Customer Rating: 3.5 out of 5 (based on 70 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $6.99
Used from: $3.20
Average Customer Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (based on 12 reviews)
Like this Answer?

"There is little you can do..."

 by busterandbabs on Dec 10 2007 (26 months ago)
Official Rating

Other then keep talking to her. Does your husband have contact with his ex? How does she feel about this. Maybe you can all work together? I know it is hard to work together, but you must. No matter what you think of his ex it is important that you all try to come together in terms of the child. I know first hand that it took my ex and I years to do this. But he was able to come to my home for our sons 18th birthday and we shook hands on a job well done. It was almost sad in a way. We had become such good friends over the years when it came to our son that it was kinda like a goodbye! Really it was seeing our son reach legal age where he can make choices on his own and sharing pride in him together. We have him to our home the day before major holidays. My son by age 6 hated switching homes on holidays so we just made special days to do them together. I am remarried and have 3 other children and I just needed to let go of the BAD person I perceived him to be and just see him as my sons dad. All issued had to be buried. It was HARD work!!! It is well worth it however and the child will thank you for it!! I even chat with his wife from time to time and also have their daughter come to stay with us to spend time with her brother. It is maybe the hardest thing that you ever have to do. I know for my husband as a step-dad it has been hard not to step in if we are fighting and take sides. It is hard for him to not let my anger spill off onto him. But we all stepped up to bat and we did it!! What better gift can be given to a child then having parents, step-parents and all communicating together and loving the child. We will all be side by side at his graduation and have a party at my home afterwards.
Sources: Life
Like this Answer?

"some questions need to be answered"

 by tuppence on Dec 10 2007 (26 months ago)
Official Rating

1.  Is she both eneuretic and encopretic?  (both pee and poo )

 

2.  Is she brain damaged or retarded (two different things)?

 

3.  Have you talked to the biological mother about it?

 

4.  How long ago was the divorce between the natural parents?

 

5.  Has a doctor been consulted?

 

 

The vast majority of children WANT to grow up.  So you have here a child who may have a biological problem involving something below the head, some kind of brain damage or retardation, or she is trying to cope with some kind of psychological trauma. 

 

Before anyone can give you any real advice, those five questions above must be answered and you need professional input on the situation.

Like this Answer?

"First of all, it isn't her fault. What's going on in her home?"

 by Llambo on Dec 10 2007 (26 months ago)
Official Rating

Suggest you lighten up with her and just let her know what a big girl she is when she does use the bathroom.  I think if she were my child, I'd want to find out what is going on in her primary home and you might start by taking the child to a child psychologist.

Any criticisms, denigration, teasing, or anger will have the exact opposite effect that you desire.
Like this Answer?

"Who is parenting?"

 by 4tnee on Dec 10 2007 (26 months ago)
Official Rating

Who is parenting? Mom and Dad or the child?

 

Someone needs to step up to the plate (or pot) and take control of the situation, and it would not be appropriate for you to do so.  Judging just from this one big problem, it would seem that your step-daughter is being spoiled.  All adults involved in her life will pay for that in the future, so something needs to change very soon.  Either Dad or Mom (preferably both) need to put their foot down, ignore the temper tantrums, and make her gradually take the big step that she should have taken long ago.

 

I am always amazed when parents say, "I know she should be doing this, but she says she doesn't want to."  Tough!  She'll get over it.  I would bet a lot of money that nobody has ever been emotionally scarred over toilet training.  I would also bet that is where the problem lies - the parents don't want to hurt the little munchkin's feelings.  Too bad.  Mom and Dad need to get tough now or suffer much more later.  As for the child's emotional scars, just imagine how bad those scars from other kids will be when they learn that she doesn't use the toilet.

 

What will be next?  "I know she should learn her spelling, but she says she doesn't want to."  "She should wear a top in public, but she doesn't like to wear tops."  Sounds extreme, but so does this problem - I mean, really - still in diapers at 5-years old?

 

Bottom line: stop letting the child be the parent.

Sources: 22-years of parenting experience
Like this Answer?




Ask a question of your own:


 

Latest post on this question's discussion board:

If the mother will not even talk with your husband, it is time to see a lawyer about custody rights. This child is clearly being talked to by her mother regarding you both and this kid is being pulled straight down the middle. That has to stop. DO NOT put the burden on the child, however. She is only reacting to a very, very nasty situation and wanting to stay little, probably.
Read more & discuss (4 comments)