Dismiss

askville homepage
Asked by flynnra1 24 months ago ( Send a Compliment)

Details:

I have to write a paper applying Weber's concept of rationalization to some aspect of modern life. The church growth movement has rightly tried to bring more people into the church, but in doing so it has downplayed important church roles. We now have a generation of people who don't know a thing about theology, but simply attend the church that is most "fun" and appealing. Has the church shot itself in the foot? It this an example of rationalization?


0
Forward to Friends Forward to friends
Discuss this question (3 comments) why can't I answer? add to Digg Digg it! add to Facebook Add to Facebook Report abuse

av-answers (2)
(3)
 
show all details - hide all details

"I'm going with "no""

Hightest Level: 2 by searchjedi on Dec 02 2007 (24 months ago)
Official Rating
Three stars
For your example to hold true to Weber's rationalization, the end goal would have to be to get people in the church doors, which the Growth Movement (Seeker Movement) is doing *exceedingly well*.  Although it is a part of the process, the real goal of the church is to lead people to Christ... and for that purpose I think the Growth Movement, without sound theology is largely ineffectual.

Has the church shot itself in the foot by compromising theology for the sake of popularity?  Yes, I believe it has.  It's the equivalent of "preaching another gospel."  Many of the churches in the midst of the seeker movement are all about Heaven on Earth, basically... Be good, feel good, and be wealthy.  You will be hard pressed to find this in biblical or historical Christianity.  "In this world you will have trouble" not "In this world you will have a three car garage."

If any church waters down the Gospel to make it more palatable they're taking a huge risk.  Even if the new visitors convert; the next generation of believers, fed all milk and no meat, will be completely unprepared  to offer even the most basic apologetic.

1Pe 3:15   but sanctify Christ as Lord in your hearts, always {being} ready to make a defense to everyone who asks you to give an account for the hope that is in you, yet with gentleness and reverence;

Sources: www.blueletterbible.org

searchjedi's Recommendations
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $22.99
Used from: $7.60
Average Customer Rating: 4.0 out of 5 (based on 26 reviews)
Product Image
Amazon List Price: $69.95
Used from: $52.92
Like this Answer? Thumb Up (0)

"churches have to meet the needs of young people or they will become relics of the past."

by sallyjo on Nov 29 2007 (24 months ago)
Official Rating
One and a half stars
i go to church and see mostly older people.  if theology isn't presented in an up-to-date "fun" manner, young people will not go and your question will be moot.
Sources: myself
Like this Answer? Thumb Up (0)




Or ask a question of your own:


 

Latest post on this question's discussion board:

yes the church has shot itself in the foot. no, it's not an example of weber's rationalism. rationalism doesn't apply well to social entities with values like churches.
Read more & discuss (3 comments)