Topics: health, grean tea, food, tea
Asked by KuriousKat 35 months ago

Details:

I'm living in Europe, but have been watching friends from the U.S. bring over individual packets of powder that you mix with bottled water to make cold green tea. Very cool!

My question is, do these "instant" green tea powdered mixes have the same health benefits as green tea brewed from tea bags?


0
 Forward to friends
 Discuss this question (0 comments) why can't I answer? Report abuse

av-answers (3)
 
Show all details, Hide all details

"They don't have as many antioxidants."

 by LessonPlansPlus.com on Mar 19 2007 (35 months ago)
 Best Answer
Official Rating

I had wondered the same thing since I love sweet green tea in a can and so I did a little reading.  I came across this article at Prevention’s website:

http://www.prevention.com/article/0,5778,s1-3-71-217-1779-1-P,00.html

The article answers your question in more depth than the summary I’ve included.  In the article they breakdown the antioxidant power of various forms of tea preparation.  Antioxidants are the chemicals that supposedly pack big health benefits.  Here is the chart that summarizes their findings:


   Antioxidant Power
   Preparation Brand   Power Rating   
   Overnight fridge
tea
Salada Green Tea (bags)   Excellent   
   Hot water-brewed tea Salada Green Tea (bags)   Excellent   
     Tetley Original Blend (black tea, bags)   Excellent   
   Liquid concentrate tea Nestea Liquid Concentrate (green tea with honey)   Excellent   
   Overnight fridge
tea
Tetley Original Blend (black tea, bags)   Very Good   
   Bottled Tea Honest Tea Moroccan Mint (green tea)   Very Good   
     Lipton Iced Tea (sweetened, no lemon)   Very Good   
     Snapple Iced Tea (sweetened, with lemon)   Very Good   
     Arizona Iced Tea (sweetened, with lemon)   Very Good   
   Powdered tea Crystal Light Peach Tea (sugar-free)   Very Good   
   Cold water-brewed tea   Lipton Cold Brew (black tea, bags)   Very Good   
   Bottled tea Nestea Iced Tea (sweetened, with lemon)   Good   
   Powdered Tea Nestea Iced Tea (unsweetened, with lemon)   Good   
   Liquid concentrate tea Nestea Liquid Concentrate (sweetened, with lemon)   Good   

Sources: prevention.com

LessonPlansPlus.com's Recommendations
Amazon List Price: $5.95
Like this Answer?

"I think so"

 by EddieNygma on Mar 19 2007 (35 months ago)
Official Rating

I will sometimes brew my own, but I most often use an instant green tea mix that's pre-sweetened with stevia. It's this one:

Wisdom of the Ancients Instant Green Tea with Stevia, Pack of Four 4.41-Ounce Bottles
List Price: $35.96
Price: $24.00 & eligible for FREE Super Saver Shipping on orders over $25
http://www.amazon.com/Wisdom-Ancients-Instant-4-41-Ounce-Bottles/dp/B000FBMW6E/ref=sr_1_2/104-6010196-8489546?ie=UTF8&s=hpc&qid=1174346544&sr=8-2

I make a pitcher and always add a couple of extra packets of stevia to improve the taste, and honestly I can get a much better price at Vitamin Shoppe, but everything I've read suggests that it does have the same health effects as fresh brewed tea. I would imagine there's something lost in whatever process they use to make it an instant, but from my own experience I can attest that I've lost weight and gained energy from drinking it, so it certainly works.
Sources: My experience
Like this Answer?

"Matcha?"

 by LostInNW on Mar 19 2007 (35 months ago)
Official Rating

Matcha, also spelled maccha, is a fine, powdered green tea used in Japanese tea ceremony and to dye and flavour foods such as mochi and soba noodles, green tea ice cream and a variety of wagashi (Japanese confectionery). The most famous Matcha-producing regions are Uji in Kyoto (tea from this region is called "Ujicha"), Nishio in Aichi (tea from this region is called Nishiocha) both on the main island of Honshū; Shizuoka, and Northern Kyushu.

Matcha is generally expensive compared to other forms of tea, although its price depends on its quality. It can be hard to find outside Japan, as can the implements traditionally used to prepare and consume it.

image:matcha.gifA bowl of matcha on a black lacquered tray with a traditional sweet

 

Health Benefits of Tea

Tea is a dietary source of important vitamins and minerals. Tea contains Carotene, a precursor to vitamin A; Thiamin (vitamin B1); Riboflavin (vitamin B2); Nicotinic acid, Pantothenic acid, Ascorbic acid (vitamin C), vitamin B6; Folic acid; Manganese, Potassium, and Fluoride.

 

 

Health Benefits of Matcha

In addition to providing trace minerals and vitamins (A, B-complex, C, E, and K), matcha is rich in catechin polyphenols - compounds with high antioxidant activity. These compounds offer protection against many kinds of cancer, help prevent cardiovascular disease and slow the aging process. They also reduce harmful cholesterol in the blood, stabilize blood sugar levels, help reduce high blood pressure and enhance the resistance of the body to many toxins. The most important polyphenol in matcha is EGCG (epigallo-catechin gallate), which is the subject of many medical studies. Matcha has a significant amount of dietary fiber and practically no calories.

Sources: http://www.inpursuitoftea.com/
Like this Answer?




Ask a question of your own: