Asked by 2highland 29 months ago

Details:

My 30 year old daughter sends me(her dad) only a card for my birthday, but sends her mom a gift. I don't want to put her on the spot, but I would like to know why there is that discrepency. Looking for advice.


0
 Forward to friends
 Discuss this question (8 comments) why can't I answer? Report abuse

av-answers (5)
(8)
 
Show all details, Hide all details

"open the lines of communication"

 by HumanLawnDart on Aug 28 2007 (29 months ago)
 Best Answer
Official Rating

Your daughter is old enough to make her own decisions, and she is old enough to know better.  Did something happen between her mom and you that she resents?  Has her mother said things to her about you?  Nonetheless, she is 30 years old, and she is old enough to take responsibility for her actions.  I would simply ask her about it.  There may be some deep-seeded issue(s) that the two of you need to sit down and discuss (just father and daughter).

 

I actually went through a similar situation with my own father, and while I cannot give you his perspective, I can give you mine.  My father had an affair with a married woman while my parents were still married.  My father involved my baby sister in the new relationship and turned her against our mother.  My mother was (and still is) a very hard working woman who always put her family first.  My father went through a mid-life crisis, and he was selfish.  It took me three years of not speaking to him and then for him to have a massive heart attack for me to forgive him.  We did a LOT of talking while he recovered from his heart attack, and needless to say, we are very close to this day.  My parents are also very good friends, again, too (which baffles most people), but it's amazing for our family as a whole.

 

My suggestion is to sit down and talk with her...find out what she is thinking, find out what her feelings are, and most importantly, tell her what your feelings are and what you are thinking...be honest and tell her that it hurts your feelings.  You will have a new-found respect for one another, and your relationship may be even better than before!

 

Good luck!

Like this Answer?

"Have you thought about asking her?"

 by Myrealana on Aug 28 2007 (29 months ago)
Official Rating

There could be any number of reasons.

 

Maybe she doesn't know you very well and can't think of a gift.

Maybe you said something at some point that made her think you didn't want her to buy you gifts.

Maybe she's mad at you.

Maybe she thinks you have enough stuff, or that anything she can afford wouldn't be good enough.

Maybe....maybe....maybe.....

 

The only way to know for sure would be to ask the question. Just don't be accusatory. Otherwise you'll never know. Try something like:

 

"Honey, you know I love the birthday cards you get me every year, but the fact that you buy your mother gifts and not me has me worried. Have I done or said something to hurt your feelings. I certainly would hope that you would be able to tell me if I have."

Like this Answer?

"Try an Amazon wishlist"

 by britishbulldog5491 on Aug 28 2007 (29 months ago)
Official Rating

What an awkward situation and I really sympathise with you.

Would it be possible, before your next birthday, for your wife to casually ask your daughter what she is going to get you for a present, just as if she does buy you a gift. This way she may perhaps mention why she does not buy you one.

You don't say if your daughter has always been like this or if it is fairly recent, perhaps she feels that men aren't all that keen on presents whereas women are.  Meanwhile, are you difficult to buy for, is your birthday near Christmas or something like that and she assumes that the present for the one occasion covers both? Have you ever brushed off a present she has given you or have you given one away that you should have cherished?

The only suggestion I can think of is that you post a wishlist on Amazon, or elsewhere, and let it be casually known that you have put the list there to experiment to see if it makes choosimg presents for you easier.  I appreciate it is difficult but you may just have to accept that this is the way it is, you do get a card and if you let this eat away at you it will make you bitter and you may end up quarrelling with her and lose her altogether.

Hope you find the answer soon.

Sources: my own
Like this Answer?

"Maybe you're hard to shop for"

 by MightyCow_DontFollow on Aug 28 2007 (29 months ago)
Official Rating

Since she and your wife are both women, your daughter might have an easier time coming up with an idea for a present that your wife will like, but doesn't know what you would want. If she had a better idea what you might like, then she might be more likely to get you something.

I think the easiest things to do would be ask your wife about it, and see if she'll politely and discreetly bring it up with your daughter, and drop some hints yourself when your birthday gets close. Mentioning to her some music that you've been listening to, or that you really want a new pair of socks (my dad always wanted socks, go figure) might get her on the right track, and having your wife mention it to her some time when you're not around takes out any awkwardness that might happen.

Good luck getting some sweet loot
Like this Answer?

"I'm going to assume you are her father. Probably because she thinks you have all you need & she can't think of owt else"

 by METACRITIC on Aug 28 2007 (29 months ago)
Official Rating

Probably because she thinks you have all you need & she can't think of what else you might like. A mother is easy to please with even a small gift: she looks beyond the gift at the thought that has gone in to choosing the gift & at what it represents = love, thanks & appreciation. She doesn't judge, just accepts greatfully. :) Women know what women like too, so that helps. Mothers and daughters are usually very close, so know each other almost like they know themselves.

 

On the other hand, buying for a father is not so easy. If the item is not practical or to his taste, he may just disregard it & think nothing more of it. If so, why bother in the first place? She may think like this. Maybe she gives to you in other ways, but you just don't notice. Maybe she prefers to take you out or treat you to something, or just visit more often. These are great practical gifts & worth far more than any object!

 

You should not place such importance on gifts.....her love should be enough! ;)

 

Of course, if it does worry you so much, why not just casually ask her. She IS your daughter I take it: what do you have to fear! :)

Like this Answer?




Ask a question of your own:


 

Latest post on this question's discussion board:

One thing that I would cherish that does not cost much at all would be a card with a message written inside telling me about their memories growing up (only the good ones!!!) or just saying something very special to me. Not just a short sentence either. So, when a son or daughter says they don't know what to give and don't do anything - that is lame. If you are out with a parent notice what they like. If they mention a play they would like to see, you could get tickets. There is nothing wrong with gift certificates. Both my husband and I like them. Certificates to book stores, restaurants, a department stores. There are many ideas out there. My son was just going to contribute to a gift we were getting his wife and I said No, you are not. He said he did not know what to get her and I rattled off a number of things she loves. He knows these things but just got momentarily lazy about it. It means so much to be remembered on your birthday, which is only once a year. Things do not have to be expensive at all.
Read more & discuss (8 comments)